Pt 2 rent abatement blog

Part 2: Talking COVID-19 and rental abatement

07 April 2020, by Dean Croucher

Businesses’ response to COVID-19 has been rapid as many face significant revenue falls and need to put contingency measures in place immediately to mitigate as much cost as possible.

As rental costs are generally the second largest cost after people, focus has quickly turned to rental abatement and other remedies. Many businesses are desperate for relief and there is significant online commentary, advice and pleas for landlords to assist and for Government to get involved (as it has in the residential area).

Equally, there’s concern amongst landlords as they face uncertain times and potential revenue loss.

In part 2 of our blog on rent abatement and related issues, we’d like to share some further insights gained over the last few days at the coalface:

Engagement

We reiterate the need for tenants to start meaningful engagement with their landlords on a without prejudice basis. As noted in our earlier blog, while a lease is a contract, it is also a business relationship with each party reliant on the other. We are actively working with several clients and helping them with these discussions. We’re also actively talking to our landlords for our two premises. They have generally been supportive and flexible in our experience.

Know your rights

While you may choose not to seek abatement or other support from your landlord, you first need to know what’s in your lease and what your options are. You also need to be forward-looking and consider what happens if the lockdown is extended or if we go back into a lockdown phase later in the year. Understanding your lease helps inform the engagement process. We are reviewing a range of leases and lease types to identify the key provisions that could apply.

Abatement

There is general consensus that clause 27.5 of the 2012 Sixth Edition of the Auckland District Law Society (ADLS) Lease – a ‘No Access In Emergency’ provision – can activate the abatement of rent. We believe the Government-enforced Level 4 alert restrictions is an ‘emergency’ and has prevented non-essential businesses from accessing their premises to fully conduct normal business. 

As a result, we believe that for most normal, non-essential businesses, ‘a fair proportion’ of the rent and outgoings may be abated. This may also extend to car park rent where it is included in the definition of the premises. Clearly, each lease needs to be carefully checked. We are actively pursuing abatement options for clients with these lease provisions.

What is a fair proportion? 

In some cases however, tenants and landlords are finding it difficult to interpret what is ‘a fair proportion of rent and outgoings’. Our starting view is that 100% abatement should apply as the premises are not being used/cannot be used. However, there are a variety of factors that inform what is fair and how the premises are being used during the emergency. 

In some cases, a tenant will not be conducting any normal business from the premises – however, it wouldn’t be unreasonable for a landlord to argue that areas used for storage and IT server rooms remain in use and therefore are removed from the abatable area. Equally, a landlord may argue that, while the tenant may not be able to conduct normal business during the emergency, the landlord is still obliged to keep the premises operational (eg rates, insurance, security etc) and therefore it is reasonable to expect the tenant to pay its fair proportion of those outgoing costs. In the case of gross leases, some fair deduction of fixed operating expenses may be needed.

Ultimately, the solution lies within positive engagement between the parties. We are considering this point on case-by-case basis. 

Essential businesses

We’re also considering the abatement options open for essential businesses who may only have a handful of staff working. In this case, it could be fair to argue that abatement is applied on a pro rata basis – ie for those areas not occupied by essential staff.

There is also an argument that even some essential, desk-based staff are not using the workplace/premises as the Level 4 alert level requires businesses to keep staff home. As a result, desk-bound, essential workers cannot access the premises in any event regardless of the type of work they are doing.

Are there other options? 

Clearly the parties have discretion to agree an appropriate solution even if the lease is silent on abatement in these circumstances. We are seeing deals being struck where landlords are offering 50% abatement during the lockdown period as a goodwill gesture for example and other hybrid solutions. Even where abatement has been agreed, we are also seeing arrangements being made to cushion the impact on the landlord’s cashflow, including deferment of rent or extended lease terms.

As noted, these arrangements need to be carefully considered. Where tenants have leases that predate the Sixth Edition ADLS and have no access/rent abatement provisions, there may be other provisions such as force majeure or ‘frustration’, but applying these principles can be onerous. Again, engagement between the parties is critical to finding an amicable and reasonable solution.

Should tenants stop paying rent? 

We don’t think tenants should unilaterally stop rental payments without first engaging with their landlord. Equally, we don’t think landlords should automatically assume the rental is due without engaging with their tenants and understanding their financial position and circumstances and, if payment is not made, we definitely don’t think landlords should enforce penalty interest or other recovery methods at the moment. 

Where there is disagreement, the parties should truly apply the principles of reasonable endeavors to reach a solution before applying the dispute resolution options available through a typical lease.

What is Government doing? 

Grant Robertson has indicated Government is working with the Property Council and others to provide some guidance. He said on Wednesday that "Lots of tenants and commercial landlords have come to good arrangements already about that and that's to be encouraged… Unfortunately, that hasn't happened everywhere so we are looking actively at what can be done there... to support especially those small-to-medium enterprises."

Our take is that any guidance/regulation from Government will aim to deal with the landlords who are being totally unreasonable and inflexible. In these cases, they may direct landlords to abate or defer rental for the lockdown period at a minimum. Clearly it is a complex issue that governments generally don’t want to get involved with. Generally, governments prefer parties to come up with a workable commercial solution. But, in this case, we have a force majeure event and unprecedented measures may be needed.

Where are the insurers? 

There is again various commentary online (not all consistent) on the application of loss of rents insurances (for landlords) and business interruption insurance (for tenants/businesses). The initial consensus is that these policies probably have a carve out for a pandemic to let insurers off the hook (what a surprise!). Like leases, the exact provisions will come down to the policies and landlords and tenants should look closely at their policies with their brokers/advisers. 

Loss of Rents Insurance

Some ADLS leases have amendments to clause 27.5 linking any ability to abate rental to the landlord’s ability to claim on their loss of rents policy. We’ve also seen leases with an amendment to the emergency definition linking this more simply to the premises being ‘inaccessible’ due to ‘the act of a civil authority’.

Each case is somewhat unique. In our view, where the standard wording applies (ie the emergency definition in the 6th Edition which includes reference to plague and epidemic among other emergency events) or a more specific inaccessible definition, landlords should have set up their loss of rents policies to cover this type of eventuality in addition to the normal drivers for a loss of rents policy such as fire, earthquake or other damage. We believe the linking of inaccessibility to loss of rents creates an obligation on the landlord to have the appropriate policy in place.

We’ve spent 30 years working closely with tenants to support them through a wide range of lease negotiations and renegotiations. If you need some support with these conversations, please get in touch. We can help – it’s what we do.

Auckland Team (covering Auckland, Hamilton, Tauranga and northern NZ region)

rob@twentytwo.co.nz

steffi@twentytwo.co.nz

dan@twentytwo.co.nz

Wellington Team (covering Wellington and balance of NZ including South Island)

david@twentytwo.co.nz

paul@twentytwo.co.nz

chris@twentytwo.co.nz

dean@twentytwo.co.nz

...

About the author

Loves anything blue. Avoids routine and making plans. Dreams of playing golf on the senior tour. Should have been a chef or writer. Fond of chardonnay and food (any kind).

Dean is one of NZ's leading property advisers with 25+ years’ consulting experience acting for major tenants and owner-occupiers. He specialises in property strategy, tenant representation, project leadership and major transactions. He also continues to provide peer review advice across all major projects.

Other posts by this author...

05 June 2020

What's next for offices and workspaces post-COVID-19? Our research says...

Last month, we undertook market research to gauge the state of organisations’ thinking on their office requirements and workspace post-COVID-19 to give us a better understanding of how businesses are reacting to the crisis from...

Read more...

29 March 2020

COVID-19: Talking with your landlord? Getting rental abatement. That’s what we do

As businesses put emergency measures in place to cope with the rapid economic impact COVID-19 is having on all sectors, one of the areas of focus will be reviewing large fixed overhead costs such as...

Read more...

22 March 2020

Adjusting to new ways of working? That’s what we do

I’ve been following a lot of the online comms in the last few days – emails from various clients and service providers and social media chat.

Read more...

05 March 2020

How to assess if your property ‘function’ can effectively govern and manage your property, workspace or specialist facilities

Most larger organisations have either an in-house property/facilities team and/or outsourced providers managing a portfolio of owned and leased property.

Read more...

09 December 2019

Planning for 2020: Making the most of the last two weeks

Before the year runs away completely TwentyTwo's Managing Director, Dean Croucher wanted to share his quick tips on how you can prepare for next year!While many of you will still be in Q3 from a...

Read more...

01 October 2019

The Wellington CBD office market is heading towards a “perfect storm”. Tenants need to develop a savvy approach to avoid being left high and dry.

 Commercial property expert Dean Croucher shares his insights on the buoyant Wellington CBD office market and the best ways for tenants to tackle their next property move using “strategic sourcing principles” rather than being...

Read more...

07 August 2019

Auckland office market: tenants always have options

 Recent research by Colliers highlights increasing risk that Auckland CBD office tenants will have fewer options to choose from in the future as vacancy levels sit at the lowest level seen (since records began in the mid-1990s).

Read more...

10 February 2019

NZ Police’s Digital Transformation

NZ Police’s new Digital Communications Centre was formally opened by the Minister of Police (Hon Stuart Nash) and Police Commissioner (Mike Bush) late last year.

Read more...

31 January 2019

TwentyTwo supports NZ Police to establish new Auckland headquarters

As part of our ongoing partnership with NZ Police, TwentyTwo (Dean Croucher and Rob Campbell) were engaged by Annabel Bayes (Strategic Property Adviser with NZ Police) to the lead the procurement of a new workplace for Auckland Police in Auckland City to replace the current Auckland Central Police Station at Cook Street/Vincent Street.

Read more...

11 November 2018

Why you need a Chief Property Officer at your top table

In the C-Suite of most large organisations you’ll typically find the roles of CEO, CFO, COO and even a CIO, CTO or CDO (Chief Information, Chief Technology or Chief Digital Officer).

Read more...

11 September 2018

Save money and reduce risk – understanding commercial property, the multiplier effect

New Zealanders often pride themselves on our DIY culture.

Read more...

18 June 2018

ESG: What is it? The latest hot issue traversing into the commercial property market

Sustainability, ethical impact, social responsibility – these are all terms, as business leaders, we’re very familiar with.

Read more...

04 June 2018

What the devil is hot-desking?

'Senior' correspondent Kitty Flanagan from Australia's comedy show, The Weekly, offers her insights into the workplace hot-desk offering.

Read more...

06 May 2018

The Workplace of the Future: The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Commercial Property and Workplace Design

I recently saw an article online (from a friend of mine (Glenn Blumenfeld) who runs a similar independent property advisory practice in Philadelphia) talking about the impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on the property markets – pointing out that the uptake of AI will replace many of the traditional processing/research roles in professional services firms (legal/accounting) – who have been the largest occupiers of CBD office space in the past.

Read more...

01 March 2018

The Commercial Real Estate Revolution – how Co-Working is Disrupting the Market

The demands on commercial property in New Zealand are changing, a real estate revolution is happening.

Read more...

25 February 2018

TwentyTwo Tribe - come & meet Rob our Auckland Lead

Introducing the newest member of the TwentyTwo Tribe, Rob Campbell. Rob calls Auckland home and will be heading-up TwentyTwo’s Auckland office.

Read more...

10 December 2017

Changing markets, new ideas, increasing diversity...what about 2018?

With 2017 coming to a close, here’s my take on some key markets, our diversifying client base, the corporatisation of the co-working space, the shift in corporate capital away from bricks and mortar and our...

Read more...

02 December 2017

TwentyTwo’s Tribe - meet the Newbies

2017 has been another busy year for TwentyTwo, our team continues to grow and I thought it was a good time to share the exciting new people, and their skills that have recently joined...

Read more...

12 September 2017

We are hiring a Marketing Communications Coordinator

Marketing Communications Coordinator (Part Time/Wellington or Auckland based). TwentyTwo is a leading professional services practice providing strategic property advice to government and corporate clients, from offices in Auckland and Wellington.

Read more...

07 April 2017

TwentyTwo appointed to five categories of Government Property Panel

TwentyTwo has recently been appointed to the Government Property Panel, an appointment that recognises our deep understanding and experience of working for the main Crown/Government agencies over the last 27 years.

Read more...

21 December 2016

Advocating for the Tenant at PINZ Government Property Event

At the recent Property Institute Government Property event in Wellington, TwentyTwo’s Dean Croucher joined David White from Government Property Group, Peter Dow (deputising for an unwell Maurice Clark) and Steve Maitland from Colliers to discuss...

Read more...

07 December 2016

Team TwentyTwo's Xmas parade

Team TwentyTwo celebrated the end of another fantastic year last weekend by heading up to Auckland to see Coldplay live at Mt Smart Stadium! The previous night, our team got together for a few quiet red...

Read more...

21 November 2016

Auckland CBD transformation takes shape

Major transformation of the Auckland CBD continues at pace with the demolition of the former Downtown Shopping Centre now complete (above left).

Read more...

02 November 2016

We're hiring! Full-time Property Consultant in Auckland

We are seeking outstanding professionals to join a growing team, making a difference to businesses around the country.

Read more...

08 September 2016

TwentyTwo's Paul Mautz is Property Advisor of the Year

Paul Mautz, Associate Principal at TwentyTwo, is the inaugural winner of the Property Institute of New Zealand's Property Advisor of the Year award.

Read more...

14 August 2016

Creative thinking delivers value for Commerce Commission

Faced with a rapidly growing Auckland team and a new strategic focus on Auckland, the Commerce Commission had to make a choice about exiting early from a lease and relocating within the CBD.

Read more...

09 May 2016

Procurement solution fuels major step towards biodiesel in NZ

Z Energy’s customers in Auckland, Waikato and the Bay of Plenty will soon be able to fill their tanks with ‘Z Bio D’ – a sustainable diesel which will be manufactured at its new bio-fuel...

Read more...

31 March 2016

Wellington Airport runway extension – unleashing potential

We're passionate about the success of Wellington and its contribution to the economy. Our business contributes to that success by helping organisations make better property decisions that help them unleash their potential.

Read more...

21 January 2016

Rise of the independent – why independence is better

Independence was a founding principle for TwentyTwo because we believed it was a critical differentiator that mattered to clients.Today, in our sector, we think it matters even more.

Read more...

18 December 2015

After a big year, a big day out

It's been fantastic year for TwentyTwo thanks to our hard working and talented team.So we decided to celebrate and reflect with a big day out.It was a cracker.

Read more...

15 December 2015

22 = 25

As 2015 comes to an end, it’s time for some reflection.It’s been a year of positive change and big progress for TwentyTwo.

Read more...

28 September 2015

Part 3: A journey from greenwash to best practice

In Part 3 of a series of blogs on the New Zealand Green Building Council, we review the future of NZGBC and what it offers organisations, particularly tenants and owner-occupiers…The NZGBC is 10 years...

Read more...

22 September 2015

Part 2: NZGBC builds on firm foundations

Following Part 1 published last week where we introduced the NZGBC and outlined our early involvement and renewed commitment to the Council, Part 2 gives a brief history, along with our experience of tenant/end...

Read more...

14 September 2015

Part 1: NZGBC gets the green light

TwentyTwo has recently renewed its commitment as a member of the New Zealand Green Building Council (NZGBC).And since World Green Building Week is all set for 21-27 September, we’re marking the occasion with a series of three blogs over three weeks to highlight NZGBC’s role in working to improve the quality and sustainability of NZ properties, as well as our involvement over the years.

Read more...

24 August 2015

Wellington projects make progress

Great to see some real progress on site last week with two of our projects… Cuba Central On Monday morning, I attended the ‘ground breaking’ ceremony for Cuba Central – the new Creative Technologies and Arts Centre being developed by Willis Bond for WelTec and Whitireia.

Read more...

18 August 2015

TwentyFive years of disruption for TwentyTwo

‘Disruption’ is a buzzword in the business world at present and, here at TwentyTwo, we also talk about being disruptive.About being a challenger brand.Challenging convention.

Read more...

12 August 2015

David Lambie joins TwentyTwo

Well-known and respected property adviser David Lambie has joined TwentyTwo as a Principal and Director.

Read more...

29 July 2015

Take it from the top

A recent issue of boardroom, the IOD’s bi-monthly magazine that keeps members informed of relevant governance and business issues, includes a feature written by Managing Partner Dean Croucher.

Read more...

16 June 2015

New Tenant Briefs page outlines client requirements

A key part of our unique end-to-end process is to intimately understand each property market and ensure our clients have visibility on the the widest range of accommodation and property options.

Read more...

15 June 2015

Independent advisers vs leasing brokers: Who gets you a better deal?

As a tenant thinking about leasing new premises, you have an important decision to make.Do you:.

Read more...

15 June 2015

People aren't your biggest cost – premises are!

A few months ago, I was taken back by a statement made by an industry insider – "people aren't your biggest cost – premises are".

Read more...

04 June 2015

Corenet Auckland Symposium 4

This is the last of my four blogs about the Corenet Auckland Symposium - Location, Location, Location that I attended in June.

Read more...

04 June 2015

Another great new signing!

TwentyTwo is delighted to announce our new 2014-15 season player partnership with Andrew Durante, Captain and No.

Read more...

04 June 2015

TwentyTwo appointed to advise Callaghan Innovation

TwentyTwo has been appointed to undertake a National Property Strategy for Callaghan Innovation.This work will involve some more detailed planning for their Gracefield Site.

Read more...

04 June 2015

TwentyTwo appointed to advise NZQA

TwentyTwo has also been appointed to help NZ Qualifications Authority make better use of their premises in Wellington.

Read more...

04 June 2015

TwentyTwo's workplace makeover

Following our re-brand in 2012, we decided to take some of our own medicine! To align with our strategic intent and values, Duncan and Dean developed a 'brief' in the same way we do with clients.

Read more...

04 June 2015

Phoenix Sponsorship Launch

On 24 September a number of clients joined us to celebrate the start of our sponsorship for the 2014/2015 season with Andrew Durante, Captain of the world famous Wellington Phoenix! Andrew was a real hit and...

Read more...

04 June 2015

Shaping our city skylines: Part One – Wellington

There’s a lot of positive news and activity at the moment across our three major cities, particularly in the commercial property space.

Read more...

04 June 2015

National Property Strategies: Observations from the frontline

We've completed quite a bit of work over the last 18 months helping Government Agencies with their Property Strategies.Together, we've learnt some good things which we've outlined here.

Read more...

04 June 2015

Thanks for your support this year – have a great Christmas

It's been another great year for TwentyTwo with fantastic projects and the start of a promising relationship with Exis Global Tenant Representation.

Read more...

04 June 2015

Office moves for the better

Office moves for the better is an interesting article by the UK's Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) on the roles and responsibilities around workplace procurement and design.

Read more...

04 June 2015

Conflicts of interest – a “spreading cancer in corporate real estate”

A robust, well-researched white paper released by Gail Corder Fischer of US tenant representation business Fischer explains how corporate tenants might be “leaving more money than they realise on the table when they place their property portfolios in the hands of large real estate brokerages that serve multiple stakeholders”.

Read more...

04 June 2015

Workplace design and productivity: are they inextricably linked?

In a recent rummage through some old research papers, we unearthed a brilliant paper from the RICS Property in the Economy Series entitled 'Workplace Design and Productivity: Are They Inextricably Linked?'.

Read more...